Halo Reach Beta Forum
  • Subject: This game doesnt cater to casuals, COD players or..
Subject: This game doesnt cater to casuals, COD players or..

I liked it, and I guess I can be referred to as a "casual", Call of Duty player, and anything else people can label others as. No, I don't accept everything Bungie throws at me, I just wasn't disappointing.

  • 05.20.2010 9:33 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

"Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind." - Albert Einstien

It is an entirely new game that takes place in the same universe.

- The main characters are different
- The story is different
- Mechanics are different

The only things that applies to Reach that is part of the other games is the enemies you fight, the weapons you use (only partially) and the universe your in.

Other than that, it is a different game.

Like Halo Wars or ODST.

  • 05.20.2010 9:37 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Posted by: UL7IM4 G33K
It is an entirely new game that takes place in the same universe.

- The main characters are different
- The story is different
- Mechanics are different

The only things that applies to Reach that is part of the other games is the enemies you fight, the weapons you use (only partially) and the universe your in.

Other than that, it is a different game.

Like Halo Wars or ODST.
...That's pretty much what I said, only with a lot of reasons I don't care about.

  • 05.20.2010 9:41 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Halo in the 1950's
92% of teens moved on to rap music. If your part of the 8% that stayed with rock, rock hard my friend and put this in your sig

I don't know if it the fact that i haven't played the bata that much. But to me Halo Reach is just Halo 3 with jetpacks. On the subject i think bungie is catering to the casual players. But thats just me

[Edited on 05.20.2010 9:50 PM PDT]

  • 05.20.2010 9:47 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: Horse Repairman
Posted by: xCrimsonLegendx
You forgot a demographic.
It cators to those of us that think Halo was getting stale as -blam!- and needed something new to keep the franchise fun.

This isn't Halo 4, it's something new.

Just because you don't like it doesn't mean those of us who do don't exist or are Bungie fanboys.

To be honest it doesn't feel that different, people are acting like the entire game is changed for some reason.
A few tweaks and few features does not mean the game is poor.

Adapt or don't buy it, we don't need to hear why.
Your logic fails. If you thought Halo was getting stale, YOU can go play something else. Don't complain when other people aren't happy about significant changes made to games that did not need them.
As if your logic is so much better Mister Spock.

It doesn't matter, I'm not here to fight with anonymous people on the internet.

I'll do my best not to complain if you try to understand that some of us like the changes.

  • 05.20.2010 10:27 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Halo 2 player until the end. Halo 3 will just never replace it, I am sorry Bungie but I know you can do better.
I'm a girl, get over it and move on.

Halo 2 Support!
I miss it so....

Id be curious to hear what would make them complain. What could bungie have done to reach to make them not like it, because it seems like most of the people around here will drink up any kind of kool aid bungie whips up. Even if its -blam!- flavored.

I loled...
It does seem that way doesn't it... Most people here in the forums are either strict on saying it is 'awesome' or saying it sucks donkeys.
I have tried not to carry either direction given Halo's history and my general love of the games, minus odst and partly Halo 3...
I had hope for Reach, I still slightly do... The changes are crap and just don't feel like halo. But truth be told there isn't a lot we can do about it. And all the nerds who stare at these forums will 'troll' saying others are 'trolls' (honestly if your going to stop to read it, why not make a reasonable response thats thought out? Instead of telling people they are 'trolls' or that their opinions are garbage.
I would assume that people in this forum are here because they like this game a lot... and are here to make a difference not be a bunch of low life fat kids who are staring at these web pages like a fat kid at cake.
Yes we all love cake, but not as much as that hungry fat kid. lol


hmmm blam flavored... if I didn't know that was a cuss word it would probably be funnier to me.

I am a rare poster / visiter to the forums. However I have this account since I made my xbox live tag. Halo 2 was the only real reason I got xbox live in the first place... Now I find I have little to nothing to do with my spare time but stick my thumbs up my ass and stare at some other slightly amusing game (which may or may not be multi and more than likely one a friend doesn't have)

[Edited on 05.20.2010 10:30 PM PDT]

  • 05.20.2010 10:28 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: DONU7
  • user homepage:

Posted by:xTCx Reloaded
Im pretty sure i could have read The Bible faster than all of those posts.

Greatest H3 Match EVER

Posted by: Canadian from SV
Its agonizingly slow pace kills the game for most competitive/skilled players.

5sk is not slow. Especially with team shot. If you were to increase the kill times team shot would be absolutely ludicrous and 1v1's would become meaningless.


Its slow kill times kill it for COD players.

Mother-**** call of duty. Seriously, people complain that this isn't Halo 2 or 3. That doesn't make enough sense since this is still Halo. But comparing it to CoD is just ridiculous.


Its emphasis on teamwork and complex systems you must learn kill it for casuals.

It's so difficult to learn to spam L and armor-lock. Oh and sprint and melee. Last but not least, the tried and true holding the left-stick down, around a corner, with a shotgun or sword... Damn! That's some really complex stuff, especially compared to previous Halo titles!


It really seems like they failed to appease any section of the community with reach. With HCE, H2, H3 the game had that easy to learn difficult to master feel that made it easily accessibly but also allowed for a competitive community to form.

Halo 3 was also not difficult to master. It was rather difficult to in essence, dumb down from the incredible depth of Halo 2. Halo 3 has very little in comparison to it, and is just as average as the other FPS's.


On the flip side that huge gap in skill doesnt seem to exist either. Its a very slow game that relies more on tactics than it does on skill. The problem is that the tactics are not THAT complex. Essentially everyone who "gets the game" will get stuck together and have a hard time breaking away.

sigh /rant


You're describing the same issue with Halo 3. The issue is there is this huge stigma in the inside and outside the Halo community that basically states that you have to satisfy the casual crowd. Because if you make a game that's supposed to be competitive you'll scare them away, and the self-labeled casuals are the "majority" of the community. Which is B.S. because if you're playing a game that's a 1v1, you're not going there to just stand there and get shot at. You're going to run around, shoot people, and enjoy winning. A game built so that people don't have to learn anything, and just shoot you to win, is a very crappy game. It's the kind of game that belongs on your I-phone. Anyways, this is a tangent.

The skill-gap doesn't exist because people don't want to learn and game producers listen. There's no more thought that maybe the reason why I'm playing versus is because I want to win. I can be casual and talk with my friends while playing and not care if I win or lose, but that's my choice to not give 100% on a game. No other event where two people are up against each other have rules made so that I can put zero effort and still win. Seriously, you don't put bricks in the gloves of one boxer just because he doesn't want to work to win.

Last thing I want to say is that the tactics in Halo have evolved to the point where there's nothing new and Bungie is sticking to what only works at the bare minimum. The people here in the community are made up mostly of people who don't like camping in a corner and tossing endless nades, but we do it anyways because that's the simple, easy way of winning. That's what Halo's become. There's no incentive to do anything BUT take the easy way out. People will quickly cover the "skill-gap" once they figure out all you gotta do is spam grenades and corner camping because that's how you win. Even the casual player wants to win. Which is why there's such a big issue of making the issue hard on casual players, they can't win without putting forth the effort.

  • 05.20.2010 11:18 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

1.Halo
2.Splinter Cell
3.Super Smash Bros
4.Elder Scrolls
5.Tomb Raider
6.Medievil
7.Muppet Racemania
8.Knights Of The Old Republic
9.Hogs Of War
10.Max Payne

Posted by: Horse Repairman
Posted by: xCrimsonLegendx
You forgot a demographic.
It cators to those of us that think Halo was getting stale as -blam!- and needed something new to keep the franchise fun.

This isn't Halo 4, it's something new.

Just because you don't like it doesn't mean those of us who do don't exist or are Bungie fanboys.

To be honest it doesn't feel that different, people are acting like the entire game is changed for some reason.
A few tweaks and few features does not mean the game is poor.

Adapt or don't buy it, we don't need to hear why.
Your logic fails. If you thought Halo was getting stale, YOU can go play something else. Don't complain when other people aren't happy about significant changes made to games that did not need them.


"If you like what's already there, play it instead of asking every game be like it"

The gameplay in Beta certainly was better than it was in Halo3. Halo3 was slow, simple and AR+melee/BR were everything people used excluding power weapon whoring. Reach might be just a bit slower but it is a lot more complex and has variety.

Whether this game beats Halo1 and 2 is up to the campaign, other multiplayer maps, modes and gameoptions, possible firefight and other stuff we haven't seen.

  • 05.21.2010 12:20 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

your right, noone at all was satisfied with reach. not a single person liked it. and all the people you see defending it on the forums, all my friends and even me are what? robots?

  • 05.21.2010 12:39 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: ubercow92
your right, noone at all was satisfied with reach. not a single person liked it. and all the people you see defending it on the forums, all my friends and even me are what? robots?

Sorry but I liked it, and I was fairly dissapointed by Halo 3 since it hardly changed anything except make it more simple than Halo 2.

  • 05.21.2010 1:06 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

This beta was really fun to me.

  • 05.21.2010 1:12 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: sLiMeWiRe
Posted by: ubercow92
your right, noone at all was satisfied with reach. not a single person liked it. and all the people you see defending it on the forums, all my friends and even me are what? robots?

Sorry but I liked it, and I was fairly dissapointed by Halo 3 since it hardly changed anything except make it more simple than Halo 2.

you misread, i like it too. you commented on my thread where i said i liked it...

  • 05.21.2010 1:15 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Team Skepsis are the best

Posted by: Andfx8
This beta was really fun to me.
STOP LYING
The OP has already said that nobody likes Reach, so stop pretending you do!!!

  • 05.21.2010 1:19 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Im a boss what else it there to say? im also the coolest person in the universe! you reading this proves that!

The game play is wayyyyyy two slow.. every game ends at 42-48 kills or 50 kills with 10 seconds on the clock! Halo 3 games were over in about 7miniutes. vs 15

  • 05.21.2010 5:39 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

The Venerable

I'm sick and tired of the human race.

Not sure what "category" I am but the game caters to me just fine. I like Tekken, GTA4, Rock Band, Guitar Hero, CE, H2, H3, COD4, WaW, MW2 and Reach to name just a few.

Every iteration of Halo since CE has been very different than the previous. Similar characters and story but very different game play. Reach continues this "tradition" and I happen to like it more than H3 so far. We'll see that happens come launch time but I personally always expect subsequent games to be very much different from their previous counterparts.

  • 05.21.2010 5:51 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: DONU7
Posted by: Canadian from SV
Its agonizingly slow pace kills the game for most competitive/skilled players.

5sk is not slow. Especially with team shot. If you were to increase the kill times team shot would be absolutely ludicrous and 1v1's would become meaningless.


Long kill times kill 1v1s not short. When you cant kill 1 opponent without him escaping, you NEED to teamshot. When you cant kill multiple opponents with one clip, you NEED to teamshot. As it is right now teamshooting is everything, 1v1s are nothing.

  • 05.21.2010 6:09 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: Canadian from SV
Posted by: DONU7
Posted by: Canadian from SV
Its agonizingly slow pace kills the game for most competitive/skilled players.

5sk is not slow. Especially with team shot. If you were to increase the kill times team shot would be absolutely ludicrous and 1v1's would become meaningless.


Long kill times kill 1v1s not short. When you cant kill 1 opponent without him escaping, you NEED to teamshot. When you cant kill multiple opponents with one clip, you NEED to teamshot. As it is right now teamshooting is everything, 1v1s are nothing.


Sweet, I love how teamshooting is sooo important in this game yet when you go in to matchmaking by yourself you pretty much can't teamshoot.

So basically you have to make a team of 4 and practice together constantly to make this game work because it relies on teamshooting?

Get out of here.

  • 05.21.2010 6:13 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

I agree. I believe its a slow game that takes no skill.

  • 05.21.2010 6:17 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: M0 Murder0
Posted by: Canadian from SV
Posted by: DONU7
Posted by: Canadian from SV
Its agonizingly slow pace kills the game for most competitive/skilled players.

5sk is not slow. Especially with team shot. If you were to increase the kill times team shot would be absolutely ludicrous and 1v1's would become meaningless.


Long kill times kill 1v1s not short. When you cant kill 1 opponent without him escaping, you NEED to teamshot. When you cant kill multiple opponents with one clip, you NEED to teamshot. As it is right now teamshooting is everything, 1v1s are nothing.


Sweet, I love how teamshooting is sooo important in this game yet when you go in to matchmaking by yourself you pretty much can't teamshoot.

So basically you have to make a team of 4 and practice together constantly to make this game work because it relies on teamshooting?

Get out of here.


I guess that would be the case if you have extreme tunnel vision or something. Not hard to see your teammate is shooting and shoot the guy hes shooting.

  • 05.21.2010 6:18 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: Canadian from SV
This game doesnt cater to casuals, COD players or competitive players. It doesnt cater to anyone.

Its agonizingly slow pace kills the game for most competitive/skilled players.

Its slow kill times kill it for COD players.

Its emphasis on teamwork and complex systems you must learn kill it for casuals.


It really seems like they failed to appease any section of the community with reach. With HCE, H2, H3 the game had that easy to learn difficult to master feel that made it easily accessibly but also allowed for a competitive community to form.

Reach seems like it will be very hard for new players to pick up with bloom ,AAs, and a huge emphasis on teamwork to the point where getting kills by yourself is very difficult. Its no longer a pick up the game and shoot people ordeal. People who are new to the game will get destroyed simply because they dont understand the basics of the game.

On the flip side that huge gap in skill doesnt seem to exist either. Its a very slow game that relies more on tactics than it does on skill. The problem is that the tactics are not THAT complex. Essentially everyone who "gets the game" will get stuck together and have a hard time breaking away.

sigh /rant


Well conceived post my friend! I think you're onto something. What you say is hard to argue with.

  • 05.21.2010 7:23 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

mongooses are the best. Remember that.

Do you like to forge? Want a place to share your maps? Want to join a friendly forging group? Plasmic Forgers

Well obviously it catered to me, I liked it. I guess I'm not one of the above type of gamer.

  • 05.21.2010 7:37 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

I love Halo Reach so it definitely caters to me. Looks like your pathetic philosophy fails miserably. /thread.

  • 05.21.2010 7:40 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: blyx


"Its agonizingly slow pace kills the game for most competitive/skilled players."

What game are you playing?

"Its slow kill times kill it for COD players."

COD players should play COD... cause bungie doesnt want to be like COD... they like being better than COD...

"Its emphasis on teamwork and complex systems you must learn kill it for casuals."

...Wouldn't the teamwork aspect make it so it ADDS catering to those who were competitive in halo 3 and people who love team games like rainbow six or gears of war?


no no dotn tell him that....it seems that for him teamwork is bad thing,now the BR is gone you need to cooperate to be succesful.

OP, if the emphasis on teamwork an complex system is hated by noobs,it would be worshipped by pros.you are contradicting yourself.
Team work is agood thing and it exists in Reach.
Dont believe me???try playing the first phase of Invasion and be an elite with NOONE in your team cooperating and have a tight spartan team.they will destroy you

  • 05.21.2010 8:10 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: Canadian from SV
Posted by: DONU7
Posted by: Canadian from SV
Its agonizingly slow pace kills the game for most competitive/skilled players.

5sk is not slow. Especially with team shot. If you were to increase the kill times team shot would be absolutely ludicrous and 1v1's would become meaningless.


Long kill times kill 1v1s not short. When you cant kill 1 opponent without him escaping, you ARE A NOOB. When you cant kill multiple opponents with one clip, you ARE A NOOB. As it is right now teamshooting is everything, 1v1s are nothing.


fix's
wow then how did a defeat many guys in 1 v 1 with DMR or AR??

  • 05.21.2010 8:13 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Fortes fortuna adiuvat.

Posted by: SX P a n d a
Obviously does cater to some people as some people do like it.

Pointless rant is pointless.

  • 05.21.2010 8:19 AM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas